The five most underwhelming World Series Champions
First off, sorry for the hiatus, I just really didn't feel like posting anything for a while. But now that spring training has started and the madness of March is upon us, hopefully I will be more inspired. Anyway, the topic here is the fie most underwhelming World Series Champions ever. Not necessarily the worst champions ever, just the teams that didn't really stand out compared to the rest of the teams that year, but won the World Series anyway.
5. 1940 Cincinnati Reds
This team basically got manager Bill McKechnie into the Hall of Fame. Besides McKechnie, the 1940 Reds had only one other Hall of Famer, catcher Ernie Lombardi, and he was injured for much of the second half and had only three at bats in the World Series. What's interesting about this team is that a lot of their key players were picked up off the scrap heap. First baseman Frank McCormick, who had 127 RBIs in 1940 and was the NL MVP that season, was rejected by the New York Giants. second baseman Lonny Frey previously played for Brooklyn and Chicago. 3rd Baseman Bill Werber, often remembered as the clubhouse leader was purchased from the Philadelphia Athletics after a holdout, and had previously played with the Red Sox and Yankees. Pitcher Bucky Walters, who won 22 games in 1940, was a failed third baseman who was sold to a minor league team by the Boston Braves before becoming a pitcher with the Phillies, who promptly screwed up and traded him to the Reds. This team wasn't full of superstars, but they had a lot of good players and won 100 games in 1940, despite injuries to Lombardi and the suicide of his backup, Willard Hershberger. The 1940 Reds were a good team, but most baseball fans probably have no clue who most of these guys are, so that's why it's on this list.
4. 1997 Florida Marlins
The team that bought the World Championship, and sold everything away soon after. Of the players on this team, the guys with the best chance of making the Hall of Fame are Gary Sheffield, who didn't have a particularly good season in 1997, and Kevin Brown. I think it's safe to say that neither one of those guys are first ballot Hall of Famers. Plus, this team was easy to dislike, not only because of their mercenary nature but because they had jerks like Sheffield, Brown, and Bobby Bonilla on the team. The team won 92 games to get the Wild Card, went through San Francisco and Atlanta in the playoffs, then played the most boring seven game World Series of all-time against the Cleveland Indians. All of this despite having two guys, Mosies Alou and Charles Johnson, performing above expectations, and getting disappointing seasons out of Jeff Conine, Sheffield, Luis Castillo, and Al Leiter. The main thing this team is remembered for is that owner Wayne Hyzengia traded or let go of every asset this team had, except for young guys like Castillo and Livan Hernandez, so they didn't have a chance to defend their championship. Other than that, this team was boring and hard to like.
3. 1990 Cincinnati Reds
I don't mean to pick on Cincinnati, but if you look at this team and their stats, they don't seem very remarkable at all. Sure, they had the Nasty Boys bullpen of Randy Myers, Rob Dibble and Norm Charlton, but other than that, they had few superstars. It's not even like they had a team full of guys with career years, as Myers, Dibble, Eric Davis, Chris Sabo, Paul O'Neill, Barry Larkin, and Jose Rijo usually put up similar or better numbers throughout their career. The only guys that had career years were second baseman Mariano Duncan and pitcher Jack Armstrong. Other than Larkin, these guys have very little chance of entering the Hall of Fame. Nevertheless, despite getting poor production out poor production out of starters Todd Benzinger, Joe Oliver, and Billy Hatcher, and despite Jack Armstrong's second half collapse, the Reds led the N.L. West wire to wire that year. Then they beat the Pirates, who had Bonds, Bonilla, Andy Van Slyke, and Doug Drabek, in the N.L.C.S. and shockingly swept the Oakland A's who had like 23 All-Stars that year, in the World Series, with Hatcher hitting .750 in the World Series. They might not have been the most talented team in baseball that year, but everything fell into place for them that year and the Reds became champions.
2. 1988 Los Angeles Dodgers
Never has a team gotten so far on the backs of two men, pitcher Orel Hershiser and outfielder Kirk Gibson, the 1988 N.L. Cy Young and MVP winners, respectively. Other than those two, this was a mediocre squad. Their bullpen pitched over their heads as Jay Howell, Alejandro Pena, and Brian Holton put up ERA over a full run below their career average (and they were usually pretty decent pitchers, in 1988, they were spectacular). Tim Leary somehow won 17 games for the Dodgers in 88, which made up for losing Fernando Valenzuela to injuries for much of the year. The pitching was good, and Hershiser was great, but the hitting suggests a team that finished below .500. They had only three players with double-digit home runs, Gibson (25), Mike Marshall (20), and John Shelby (10). The rest of the team, well, look below:
Franklin Stubbs, 242 at bats (.223/.288/.376)
Jeff Hamilton, 309 at bats (.236/.268/.353)
Mike Scoscia, 408 at bats (.257/.318/.324)
Alfredo Griffin, 316 at bats (.199/.259/.253)
Dave Anderson, 285 at bats (.249/.325/.319)
Mike Davis, 281 at bats (.196/.260/.270)
Sure, they played in a tough hitters park, but still, the 1988 Dodgers gave over 1,800 at bats to players who had little or no production. Yet, they won the N.L. West pretty easily, and beat out two teams that were very talented, the Mets (despite the team hitting .214 in the NLCS) and the A's, to win the World Series, even though Gibson struggled in the N.L.C.S. and had only one at-bat in the World Series (and what an at-bat it was).
1. 1945 Detroit Tigers
The Tigers won 88 games in the regular season in a watered down league (due to WWII), then beat the Cubs in seven games in the World Series. These Tigers had some good players. Hal Newhouser and Dizzy Trout could pitch whether it was wartime baseball or not, and midway through the '45 season, they got big-time slugger Hank Greenberg back. It's a good thing they got him back, as some of these Tigers couldn't hit the water if they were in the ocean. Bob Swift, Detroit's main catcher put up a (.233/.298/.251) line in 279 at bats. Or take Skeeter Webb, in 407 at bats, the shortstop put up the following line: (.199/.254/.238). I hope he was a damn good fielder. The rest of the team was no better than league average, with the exception of the historically underrated Roy Cullenbine (.398 OBP, 93 RBIs) As for the pitching, they had Newhouser, Trout, and Al Benton, which was enough to get the Tigers a World Championship. This team had a few good players, but they also had some players who would have never started if a lot of the players weren't off on war, and I have a feeling that, if you put all the World Series champions together, and play a 1000 game schedule, this team would end up with the worst record.
5. 1940 Cincinnati Reds
This team basically got manager Bill McKechnie into the Hall of Fame. Besides McKechnie, the 1940 Reds had only one other Hall of Famer, catcher Ernie Lombardi, and he was injured for much of the second half and had only three at bats in the World Series. What's interesting about this team is that a lot of their key players were picked up off the scrap heap. First baseman Frank McCormick, who had 127 RBIs in 1940 and was the NL MVP that season, was rejected by the New York Giants. second baseman Lonny Frey previously played for Brooklyn and Chicago. 3rd Baseman Bill Werber, often remembered as the clubhouse leader was purchased from the Philadelphia Athletics after a holdout, and had previously played with the Red Sox and Yankees. Pitcher Bucky Walters, who won 22 games in 1940, was a failed third baseman who was sold to a minor league team by the Boston Braves before becoming a pitcher with the Phillies, who promptly screwed up and traded him to the Reds. This team wasn't full of superstars, but they had a lot of good players and won 100 games in 1940, despite injuries to Lombardi and the suicide of his backup, Willard Hershberger. The 1940 Reds were a good team, but most baseball fans probably have no clue who most of these guys are, so that's why it's on this list.
4. 1997 Florida Marlins
The team that bought the World Championship, and sold everything away soon after. Of the players on this team, the guys with the best chance of making the Hall of Fame are Gary Sheffield, who didn't have a particularly good season in 1997, and Kevin Brown. I think it's safe to say that neither one of those guys are first ballot Hall of Famers. Plus, this team was easy to dislike, not only because of their mercenary nature but because they had jerks like Sheffield, Brown, and Bobby Bonilla on the team. The team won 92 games to get the Wild Card, went through San Francisco and Atlanta in the playoffs, then played the most boring seven game World Series of all-time against the Cleveland Indians. All of this despite having two guys, Mosies Alou and Charles Johnson, performing above expectations, and getting disappointing seasons out of Jeff Conine, Sheffield, Luis Castillo, and Al Leiter. The main thing this team is remembered for is that owner Wayne Hyzengia traded or let go of every asset this team had, except for young guys like Castillo and Livan Hernandez, so they didn't have a chance to defend their championship. Other than that, this team was boring and hard to like.
3. 1990 Cincinnati Reds
I don't mean to pick on Cincinnati, but if you look at this team and their stats, they don't seem very remarkable at all. Sure, they had the Nasty Boys bullpen of Randy Myers, Rob Dibble and Norm Charlton, but other than that, they had few superstars. It's not even like they had a team full of guys with career years, as Myers, Dibble, Eric Davis, Chris Sabo, Paul O'Neill, Barry Larkin, and Jose Rijo usually put up similar or better numbers throughout their career. The only guys that had career years were second baseman Mariano Duncan and pitcher Jack Armstrong. Other than Larkin, these guys have very little chance of entering the Hall of Fame. Nevertheless, despite getting poor production out poor production out of starters Todd Benzinger, Joe Oliver, and Billy Hatcher, and despite Jack Armstrong's second half collapse, the Reds led the N.L. West wire to wire that year. Then they beat the Pirates, who had Bonds, Bonilla, Andy Van Slyke, and Doug Drabek, in the N.L.C.S. and shockingly swept the Oakland A's who had like 23 All-Stars that year, in the World Series, with Hatcher hitting .750 in the World Series. They might not have been the most talented team in baseball that year, but everything fell into place for them that year and the Reds became champions.
2. 1988 Los Angeles Dodgers
Never has a team gotten so far on the backs of two men, pitcher Orel Hershiser and outfielder Kirk Gibson, the 1988 N.L. Cy Young and MVP winners, respectively. Other than those two, this was a mediocre squad. Their bullpen pitched over their heads as Jay Howell, Alejandro Pena, and Brian Holton put up ERA over a full run below their career average (and they were usually pretty decent pitchers, in 1988, they were spectacular). Tim Leary somehow won 17 games for the Dodgers in 88, which made up for losing Fernando Valenzuela to injuries for much of the year. The pitching was good, and Hershiser was great, but the hitting suggests a team that finished below .500. They had only three players with double-digit home runs, Gibson (25), Mike Marshall (20), and John Shelby (10). The rest of the team, well, look below:
Franklin Stubbs, 242 at bats (.223/.288/.376)
Jeff Hamilton, 309 at bats (.236/.268/.353)
Mike Scoscia, 408 at bats (.257/.318/.324)
Alfredo Griffin, 316 at bats (.199/.259/.253)
Dave Anderson, 285 at bats (.249/.325/.319)
Mike Davis, 281 at bats (.196/.260/.270)
Sure, they played in a tough hitters park, but still, the 1988 Dodgers gave over 1,800 at bats to players who had little or no production. Yet, they won the N.L. West pretty easily, and beat out two teams that were very talented, the Mets (despite the team hitting .214 in the NLCS) and the A's, to win the World Series, even though Gibson struggled in the N.L.C.S. and had only one at-bat in the World Series (and what an at-bat it was).
1. 1945 Detroit Tigers
The Tigers won 88 games in the regular season in a watered down league (due to WWII), then beat the Cubs in seven games in the World Series. These Tigers had some good players. Hal Newhouser and Dizzy Trout could pitch whether it was wartime baseball or not, and midway through the '45 season, they got big-time slugger Hank Greenberg back. It's a good thing they got him back, as some of these Tigers couldn't hit the water if they were in the ocean. Bob Swift, Detroit's main catcher put up a (.233/.298/.251) line in 279 at bats. Or take Skeeter Webb, in 407 at bats, the shortstop put up the following line: (.199/.254/.238). I hope he was a damn good fielder. The rest of the team was no better than league average, with the exception of the historically underrated Roy Cullenbine (.398 OBP, 93 RBIs) As for the pitching, they had Newhouser, Trout, and Al Benton, which was enough to get the Tigers a World Championship. This team had a few good players, but they also had some players who would have never started if a lot of the players weren't off on war, and I have a feeling that, if you put all the World Series champions together, and play a 1000 game schedule, this team would end up with the worst record.
